论文标题

算法公平和结构不公正:女权主义政治哲学的见解

Algorithmic Fairness and Structural Injustice: Insights from Feminist Political Philosophy

论文作者

Kasirzadeh, Atoosa

论文摘要

数据驱动的预测算法被广泛用于自动化和指导高风险决策,例如保释和假释建议,医疗资源分配和抵押贷款分配。然而,据报道,有害成果偏向脆弱的群体。不断增长的研究领域被称为“算法公平”,旨在减轻这些有害的偏见。它的主要方法包括提出数学指标来解决算法偏见的输出造成的社会危害。这些指标通常是由政治和法律哲学家提出的分配正义理想的或实质上植根于分配正义的理想的动机。相比之下,女权主义政治哲学家对社会正义的观点在很大程度上被忽略了。一些女权主义哲学家批评了分配正义的范式,并提出了纠正修正案以克服其局限性。本文将女权主义政治哲学的一些关键见解带入了算法公平。该论文有三个目标。首先,我表明算法公平性不适应当前范围的结构不公正。其次,我捍卫结构不公正的相关性 - 正如艾里斯·马里恩·杨(Iris Marion Young)在当代哲学文学中所启示的那样 - 与算法公平。第三,我采取了一些步骤来开发“负责任算法公平性”的范式,以纠正当前范围和算法公平实现的错误。

Data-driven predictive algorithms are widely used to automate and guide high-stake decision making such as bail and parole recommendation, medical resource distribution, and mortgage allocation. Nevertheless, harmful outcomes biased against vulnerable groups have been reported. The growing research field known as 'algorithmic fairness' aims to mitigate these harmful biases. Its primary methodology consists in proposing mathematical metrics to address the social harms resulting from an algorithm's biased outputs. The metrics are typically motivated by -- or substantively rooted in -- ideals of distributive justice, as formulated by political and legal philosophers. The perspectives of feminist political philosophers on social justice, by contrast, have been largely neglected. Some feminist philosophers have criticized the paradigm of distributive justice and have proposed corrective amendments to surmount its limitations. The present paper brings some key insights of feminist political philosophy to algorithmic fairness. The paper has three goals. First, I show that algorithmic fairness does not accommodate structural injustices in its current scope. Second, I defend the relevance of structural injustices -- as pioneered in the contemporary philosophical literature by Iris Marion Young -- to algorithmic fairness. Third, I take some steps in developing the paradigm of 'responsible algorithmic fairness' to correct for errors in the current scope and implementation of algorithmic fairness.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源