论文标题
评论基于Doring和Leuenberger（2022）的GISP2多GAS - 同位素测量的全新世温度重建的评论（2022）
Comment on Comparison of Holocene temperature reconstructions based on GISP2 multiple-gas-isotope measurements by Doring and Leuenberger (2022)
论文作者
论文摘要
Doring and Lueneberger（Doring and Leuenberger，2022年）通过比较各种重建的温度，从冰芯中的遮挡空气中进行了一项重要的研究，从冰芯中的遮挡空气进行了重建。从他们的分析中，他们得出结论，他们的D15N温度重建（D15N方法）是比较方法中最好的方法，而Kobashi等人。 D15Nexcess（Kobashi等，2017）的温度重建不应用于气候解释，因为D40AR和D15Nexcess数据不够准确。但是，他们未能认识到重要的问题以得出结论。因此，我们对这些观点进行评论，以表明他们的结论是错误的。
Doring and Lueneberger (Doring and Leuenberger, 2022) conducted an important work on Greenland temperature reconstruction from occluded air in an ice core for the Holocene by comparing various reconstructed temperatures. From their analyses, they conclude that their d15N temperature reconstruction (d15N method) is the best method among the compared methods, and Kobashi et al. temperature reconstruction with d15Nexcess (Kobashi et al., 2017) should not be used for climate interpretation because d40Ar and d15Nexcess data are not accurate enough. However, they failed to recognize important issues to reach their conclusions. Therefore, we comment on those points to make it clear that their conclusions are erroneous.
